The YouTubers are right: Jamie Costa should definitely star in a Robin Williams biopic

Robin WilliamsPhoto: Frederic Larson / The Chronicle

In the past few days, an obscure impressionist named Jamie Costa has become almost famous, thanks to a viral YouTube video that has more than 2 million views and counting. “Robin Test Footage Scene” features Costa asRobin Williams, in a scene from a supposed biopic of the actor that is neither cast nor planned.

In reality, it’s a short film that apparently was intended to make the case that Costacouldand maybeshouldplay thelate, beloved San Francisco comedian if such a biopic were made.

The short film takes place on the morning of March 5, 1982, and depicts Williams in makeup, running his lines, when his “Mork & Mindy” co-star Pam Dawber (Sarah Murphree) enters and breaks the news that John Belushi has died. Williams had been partying with the comedian the night before.

“罗宾测试Footage Scene” is at least achieving some of its intended effect. If you read the YouTube comments, the response has been hugely positive, and many people are saying that, on the basis of this one scene, Costa should be cast as Williams immediately.

Are they right? Here are my arguments in favor of Costa starring in a potential Robin Williams feature.

他是无名:Though in terms of box office, casting a bona fide star as Williams might seem the way to go, who’d want to step into those shoes? Casting an established entity to play such a familiar and beloved personality would create a clash of identities. An unknown is the way to go for the lead role. If they need stars — and the film would — they can be cast in supporting roles.

He’s the right age:Costa is 31, which means he could play Williams pre-stardom. If they need to make him older, they can always add makeup. There’s no makeup that makes anyone look younger.

He’s the right size:Williams was about 5-foot-7, and Costa looks to be about the same size. We don’t need a 6-foot-2 Williams. He wouldn’t be the same guy.

Costa really, really looks like Williams:Watch the video. It’s uncanny.

He doesn’t just sound like Williams. He can act:This is why Costa needed to make the video. A lot of impressionists can do the voice, but inhabiting the soul of the character is something else. When Costa, as Williams, gets the bad news and says, “Not John” — it’s goose bumps.

Whatever Costa doesn’t have, he can get:If a Williams biopic were ever to materialize, Costa wouldn’t just be flung in front of the camera. He’d be working with a director, and a good director would help him add whatever elements weren’t already there. For example, Williams had a spring-loaded quality, like he was about to jump out of his skin. In a full portrait, Costa would have to rope that quality in.

If they do make the movie, what a story it would be:People would be writing about this from today through the film’s opening. A relative unknown makes a video and ends up basically casting himself in a movie made to order. It’s a fairy tale. People would love this. People would be rooting for this. This would be the first time this ever happened. A “Robin” biopic, starring Costa, would have the goodwill of the entire world behind it. Then they’d just have to make a good movie.

The verdict:I’m with the YouTube commenters. I want this picture to go into productionyesterday.

Of course, there’s many a slip between the cup and the lip, as they used to say, and many amazing things that we imagine don’t end up happening. But Costa has made the case for himself. Now the ball is in Hollywood’s court.

  • Mick LaSalle
    Mick LaSalleMick LaSalle is The San Francisco Chronicle's film critic. Email: mlasalle@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @MickLaSalle